Skip to content
Coinmen Consultants LLP : Top Financial & Business Advisory Firm in India
  • About
    • About US
    • Services
      • Tax and Regulatory
        • Corporate Tax
        • International Tax
        • Regulatory Compliance
        • Global Mobility Services
        • Lower Withholding Tax Certificate
      • Transfer Pricing
      • Corporate Law
      • Financial Accounting
      • Transaction Advisory
      • Risk Advisory
    • Careers
    • Blogs
  • Startups
  • Business in India
    • Doing Business In India
    • Desks
  • Outbound
  • Get a Consultation
  • About
    • About US
    • Services
      • Tax and Regulatory
        • Corporate Tax
        • International Tax
        • Regulatory Compliance
        • Global Mobility Services
        • Lower Withholding Tax Certificate
      • Transfer Pricing
      • Corporate Law
      • Financial Accounting
      • Transaction Advisory
      • Risk Advisory
    • Careers
    • Blogs
  • Startups
  • Business in India
    • Doing Business In India
    • Desks
  • Outbound
  • Get a Consultation

Start-ups in A Muddle

How Simple Restructuring May Lead To Withdrawal Of Exemption

Written By ————

Karnik Gulati and Loveena Manaktala

Start-ups, nowadays, are preferring a dual-company structure that involve a holding company that owns 100% of the shares in a subsidiary operating company. An operating company is the entity that enters into contractual arrangements with clients, suppliers and employees.The holding company generally houses the start-up’s intellectual property (IP), common resources like management, employees, assets, etc.

Revised guidelines that were issued in June 2021 (‘revised guidelines’), that many are still unaware of, mainly discourage the dual-company structures and joint ventures. This article talks about the potential implications and grey areas that have come into picture pursuant to such revised guidelines.

As per the guidelines dated 19 February 2019 issued by Department for Promotion of Industry and Internal Trade (‘DPIIT’), an entity is considered as a ‘start-up’ if it fulfils the following conditions:

 

  • Incorporated as a private limited company or registered as a partnership firm or an LLP in India.

  • Turnover of the entity for any of the financial years since incorporation/registration does not exceed INR 100 Crore.

  • Entity is working towards innovation, development or improvement of products or processes or services, or if it is a scalable business model with a high potential of employment generation or wealth creation

It is provided that an entity formed by splitting up or reconstruction of an existing business shall not be considered a ‘Start-up’. An entity shall cease to be a start-up on achieving either of the following:

  • Completion of 10 years from the date of its incorporation/ registration or

  • If its turnover for any previous year exceeds INR 100 Crore

Revised Guidelines For (De)Recognition Of Start-Up Dated 21 June 2021 (‘Revised Guidelines’)

The revised guidelines were discreetly uploaded on the Start Up India website without any notification or circular. Further to our surprise, no one is actually talking about these, even when the potential implications pursuant to these guidelines are going to cause trouble for many existing start-ups.

Revised guidelines discourage holding-subsidiary relationship and joint ventures (JVs). An extract from the revised guidelines relating to holding-subsidiary relation, JV entities incorporated outside Indian Territory is given below:

  • Holding/Subsidiary Companies will not be permitted for recognition. Any start-up becoming holding/subsidiary of any company after recognition will be derecognized.

  • Any entity formed by Joint Venture will not be recognized. Any start-up entering into any Joint Venture will be derecognized.

  • Entities incorporated outside India will be ineligible for recognition.

  • Shareholding by Indian promoters in the start-up should be at least 51%, as per Companies Act, 2013 and SEBI (ICDR) Regulations, 2018.

Impact Of Revised Guidelines

  • Surprisingly, startups having holding-subsidiary structure have been barred for recognition as start-up. This will impact start-ups that are currently following dual-company structures or one holding for many subsidiaries structure.

  • Furthermore, the revised guidelines also discourage JVs amongst start-ups. Even though we have not seen any JVs amongst the startups yet, but it may be possible to have start-ups entering into JVs for strategic reasons including synergy benefits, etc.

  • Derecognition of already recognised start-ups will impact multiple exemptions and benefits that are available for start-ups. This includes tax holiday benefit, relaxation in public procurement norms, benefit of fast-track exit, etc.

Things To Ponder Upon For Existing DPIIT-Recognised Start-Ups

  • Process of withdrawal of start-up benefits : It is unclear as to how such derecognition will take place. No procedure has been provided so far in this regard. Will it be deemed derecognition, or there will be a voluntary intimation mechanism?

  • Hardship for genuine cases : Start-up groups intentionally park their valuable assets such as cash, intangibles, etc. in one entity for different commercial reasons and operate businesses through other entities. Commercial reasons may include value consolidation in one entity, easier management of resources, etc. The revised guidelines are discouraging the genuine group structures that have been established owing to genuine commercial reasons.

  • Curious case of convertible notes : Convertible notes are one of the most common instruments issued by start-ups for raising funds. It is to be noted that only a DPIIT-registered start-up can issue convertible notes. Once the start-up gets derecognised on the stance of becoming a holding or subsidiary, how will the convertible notes be categorised? Will that lead to violation of FEMA and Companies Law since only a DPIIT-recognised start-up can issue the convertible notes?

  • Withdrawal of exemption for Income Tax purposes : Eligible startups can avail tax holiday for 3 consecutive years anytime during first 10 years of its business operations. It will be interesting to see what happens to those startups which have already availed the tax holiday benefit – will they be asked to cough up due taxes on withdrawal of startup benefits.

  • Validity of revised guidelines : Given that the revised guidelines have not been notified as a gazetted document, can they be legally challenged in the court of law is something worth exploring

Our Comments

Even though the derecognition condition of barring the holding-subsidiary structure or forming a JV is a bit too harsh, even if it were to stay as it is, it will be helpful to grandfather the startups recognised until the notification date to ensure that the existing startups do not face any unnecessary hurdles in expanding their business. Furthermore, to give effect to the derecognition, other relevant laws including companies law, foreign exchange regulations should also be synced in line with the revised guidelines.

Related Post

  • Tax Holiday for Startups: Common Reasons for Rejection or Deferral of Application

  • All About Startup Funding In India

  • The Startup India Seed Fund Scheme

  • Tax implications in India on Startups & Investors

  • Startups and DPIIT Recognition

Recent Posts

Fast-Track Merger- Benefits, Risks and Strategic Insights

Fast-Track Merger- Benefits, Risks and Strategic Insights

Read More »
Navigating Tax Complexities for Expatriates: The Role of Tax Equalization and Hypo Tax

Navigating Tax Complexities for Expatriates: The Role of Tax Equalization and Hypo Tax

Read More »
Manufacturing Set up – Indian Transfer Pricing Outlook

Manufacturing Set up – Indian Transfer Pricing Outlook  

Read More »

How to Apply for a Lower Withholding Tax Certificate in India 

Read More »

A comprehensive guide to Special Non-Resident Rupee Account (‘SNRR’) 

Read More »

Drafting Effective Arbitration Clauses: A Guide To Streamlining Dispute Resolution

Read More »

Conducting The Arbitration Hearing: Navigating The Heart Of Dispute Resolution

Read More »

Initiating Arbitration Proceedings: Setting The Stage For Dispute Resolution

Read More »

Choosing The Right Arbitrator: Key To Successful Dispute Resolution In India

Read More »

Why Choose Business Arbitration? Navigating Disputes With Speed, Privacy, And Control

Read More »

Quick Link

About
Careers
Blog
Start ups
Services
Doing Business In India
Company Incorporation
Funding A Business In India
Direct Tax
Transfer Pricing Regulations
GST
Expatriate Tax

Business Consulting Services

Tax And Regulatory
Corporate Tax Services
International Tax
Regulatory Compliance Services
Global Mobility Services
Lower Withholding Tax Certificate
Transfer Pricing
Corporate Law Services
Financial Accounting
Transaction Advisory

About Coinmen

Founded in 2010, Coinmen Consultants LLP is an independent Financial and Business Advisory firm, offering an array of advisory services to support companies, whatever their scale or geography, in their growth trajectory. Backed by its group companies – Coinmen Consultants LLP, and Coinmen Capital Advisors LLP  – Coinmen has established its presence globally having helped over 100 businesses through projects in varying capacities.

New Delhi Head Office:


A-22, 2nd Floor, Green Park Main

Aurobindo Marg, New Delhi 110016

+91-11-4016-0160

Email: info@coinmen.com

Contact Us

Content Protection by DMCA | Cookie Policy | Privacy Policy | Disclaimer Copyright © 2026 by Coinmen. All rights Reserved.